McMillan Line
The line
The ancestry of Lucile McMillan (1905-1996), Frances Holbrook’s mother. Two streams met in Walworth County, Wisconsin: Highland Scots by way of Nova Scotia, and Long Island Quakers by way of the Hudson valley and the Catskills. Both went on to the Pacific coast, and Lucile was born at Tacoma, where her father and uncle ran McMillan Bros., druggists.
The line at a glance
McMillan. Malcolm McMillan, a settler of Lochaber, Antigonish County, Nova Scotia, about 1810 > Duncan McMillan (b. c. 1812-1816, Lochaber; to Calamus, Dodge County, Wisconsin, 1845; d. 1889, Beaver Dam) > William McMillan (1841-1927), farmer and teacher in Iowa, then of Tacoma > Alfred Ross McMillan (1884-1966), of McMillan Bros., druggists of Tacoma > Lucile. William married Harriet Ellen Adams, granddaughter of the Humphreys and Enoses of Connecticut.
Frost. William Frost of Setauket and Matinecock, Long Island (d. 1719), and Rebecca Wright > William (1674-1728) > Isaac (1717), a Quaker of Mill River Neck and then Dutchess County > George (1760-1830) > George (1791-1860), of Rensselaerville and Heart Prairie, Wisconsin > Stephen George (1826-1919) > George William (1850-1925), banker at Cloverdale and Santa Cruz, California, then of Spokane > Florence (1885-1957), who married Alfred McMillan at Spokane in 1904. Florence’s parents were second cousins: both descend from Jonathan Fairchild of East Jewett, Greene County, New York.
How sure it is
The McMillan-Frost research file (research/mcmillan/McMillan_Frost_Master_Research.md, October 2026)
proves every link from Lucile to Duncan McMillan, Robert Adams and Caroline Humphrey, Stephen G. Frost,
Richard Fairchild and William H. Bell from census, marriage, death and draft records, and Duncan’s
parents’ names from three records of his own. The Frost line above George (1791) rests on Josephine
Frost’s Frost Genealogy (1912) and is compiled, as are the Fairchild descent from Jonathan and the
Humphrey and Enos generations. Disproven, and left out: the FamilySearch McMillan chain above Malcolm;
the “Capt.” John Bell given as William H. Bell’s father; George Frost’s (1760) Revolutionary pension.
Open questions
- Malcolm McMillan’s origin in Scotland (probably Kilmallie, Lochaber), and Mary McMillan’s parents (probably William McMillan and Penuel MacDougall of Glen Urquhart).
- When McMillan Bros. was founded and closed; whether Alfred or Everett was a licensed pharmacist.
- William and Harriet’s marriage year (1862 or 1865).
- George W. Frost’s “pistol accident” at Santa Cruz, 1887, and his business at Spokane.
- Lucile’s first marriage, to Harold Oscar Smith at Tacoma in 1925.
People, oldest first
- Adam Winthrop
- Anne Winthrop documentedproven
- John Bissell
- Thomas Bowne
- John Underhill
- Elizabeth Fones compiledprobable
- Nicholas Wright
- John Bowne documentedproven
- Elizabeth Feake compiledprobable
- William Frost
- Hannah Feake compiledprobable
- Abigail Holcomb compiledprobable
- John Feke compiledprobable
- Samuel Fairchild compiledprobable
- Sarah Stockbridge inferredprobable
- John Prior compiledprobable
- James Eno compiledprobable
- Mary Wheeler documentedproven
- Elizabeth Prior compiledprobable
- Elizabeth Bowne compiledprobable
- Abigail Bissell compiledprobable
- Joseph Woodworth compiledprobable
- David Underhill documentedprobable
- Samuel Raymond documentedprobable
- James Cock documentedproven
- William Frost compiledprobable
- Hannah Feke compiledprobable
- James Enos compiledprobable
- Hannah Prior compiledprobable
- Jonathan Fairchild compiledprobable
- Eleanor Whitney compiledprobable
- Joseph Woodworth compiledprobable
- Ephraim Raymond compiledprobable
- Mary Coley
- Isaac Frost compiledprobable
- Thomas Fairchild compiledprobable
- Joseph Enos compiledprobable
- Mary Cock compiledprobable
- Mercy Dickinson compiledprobable
- Lemuel Woodworth compiledprobable
- Thomas Underhill compiledprobable
- Jonathan Fairchild compiledpossible
- Lucy Robbins
- George Frost compiledprobable
- Sarah Underhill documentedproven
- Lemuel Woodworth compiledprobable
- Lydia Winter
- Hannah Enos compiledprobable
- Joseph Humphrey compiledprobable
- Penuel MacDougall compiledprobable
- George Frost compiledprobable
- Abigail Tanner
- John Fairchild compiledprobable
- John M. Bell
- Sarah Gerow
- Catherine Clawson compiledprobable
- Nancy Woodworth compiledprobable
- Richard C. Fairchild compiledprobable
- Duncan McMillan documentedproven
- Caroline Humphrey compiledprobable
- Mary McMillan compiledprobable
- Robert Adams
- Stephen George Frost documentedproven
- Adeline Asenath Fairchild compiledprobable
- William Hamilton Bell documentedproven
- Elizabeth Fairchild documentedproven
- William McMillan documentedproven
- Harriet Ellen Adams documentedproven
- George William Frost documentedproven
- Lucy Ellen Bell documentedproven
- Alfred Ross McMillan documentedproven
- Florence Bell Frost documentedproven
- Lucille M. McMillan documentedproven
- Abigail Keyes
- Ann Raymond documentedprobable
- Ann Wright
- Anne Browne
- Benjamin Underhill compiledpossible
- Ebenezer Humphrey
- Elizabeth Holcombe
- Elizabeth Smith
- Emma Seabrook compiledprobable
- Euphemia Bethune
- Hannah Townsend documentedprobable
- Henry Whitney
- James Cock
- James Eno
- John MacDougall
- John Raymond documentedproven
- John Stockbridge
- John Whitney documentedproven
- Joseph Woodworth compiledprobable
- Josiah Clawson
- Judith Palmer
- Malcolm McMillan
- Mary Betts
- Mary Prior
- Matthew Prior
- Moses Wheeler
- Rebecca Wright documentedproven
- Richard Raymond
- Robert Feake
- Robert Seabrook
- Samuel Bissell compiledprobable
- Sarah Cock
- Thomas Fairchild
- Thomas Fones
- Thomas Holcombe
- Thomas Townsend
- Walter Woodworth
- William McMillan
- Zebulon Dickinson
Lifelines
Their families
29 spouses and children
- Richard Clifford Holbrook
- Private
- Private
- William E. McMillan
- George Emmett McMillan
- Malcolm D. McMillan
- Alice Emily McMillan
- Roy Duncan McMillan
- Fred Wheeler McMillan
- Everett E. McMillan
- Frank Harold McMillan
- Mary McMillan
- Malcolm McMillan
- Daniel McMillan
- Alexander McMillan
- Alpin McMillan
- Penuel McMillan
- Euphemia McMillan
- Sarah A. McMillan
- Jerome B. Adams
- Marian Emeline Adams
- Dora Belle Frost
- Irving W. Frost
- Frances Ruth Frost
- Phebe Ann Frost
- William Tanner Frost
- Sarah Diana Frost
- Olif G. Fairchild
- Malona Fairchild